S. A. Tokarev about Religion: The Celestial and the Terrestrial in the Soviet Context

10.33876/2311-0546/2024-4/79-93

Authors

Keywords:

S. A. Tokarev, Soviet historiography, religion, ethnography, debate

Abstract

S.A. Tokarev wrote on a variety of topics, yet his primary academic interest was the study of religion. He was a scholar of his time, holding Marxist views and approaching the analysis of religion from a materialistic perspective, but he never departed from strict and consistent logic, avoiding unquestioning acceptance of the official point of view. All this was clearly manifested in his contributions to the debate on religion that unfolded on the pages of the journal Soviet Ethnography in 1979 — 1981. In the article that initiated the discussion, S.A. Tokarev offered ethnographers his own vision of the study of religion, which extended beyond the ideologized officialism, and outlined the subject matter of the ethnographic study of religion. He posed questions that were not quite typical of his time and slightly above the ideological restrictions of the period. He expanded the issues significant for the ethnographer, while not denying but rather emphasizing the importance of the study of folk forms of religiosity — the main direction in the study of religion by ethnographers at that time (along with the study of primitive beliefs). S. A. Tokarev, one of the founders of the Soviet ethnographic school and a key figure in the development of the system of higher ethnographic education in the USSR, was a scholar of his era. But the works of scholars like him facilitated the continuity with the old school and did not fatally isolate the Soviet humanities from the global academic community. In fact, the issues raised by S. A. Tokarev are also in line with the contemporary challenges facing the ethnological/anthropological study of religion: religious identity and its relationship to other forms of cultural identity, religious conversion and related shifts in identity, different manifestations and new forms of religiosity, global religious movements, the complexities of religious statistics, the religious and the secular.

Author Biography

  • Olga Kazmina, M. V. Lomonosov Moscow State University

    Kazmina, Olga E. — Doctor of History, Head of the Department of Ethnology, Deputy Dean of the Faculty of History, Lomonosov Moscow State University (Moscow, Russian Federation). E-mail: okazmina@inbox.ru ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1708-2933

    For Citation: Kazmina, O. E. 2024. S. A. Tokarev about Religion: The Celestial and the Terrestrial in the Soviet Context. Herald of Anthropology (Vestnik Antropologii) 4: 79–93.

    References
    1. Basilov, V. N. 1995. S. A. Tokarev kak predstavitel’ russkoi kul’tury [S. A. Tokarev as a Representative of Russian Culture]. In Blagodarim sud’bu za vstrechu s nim. O Sergee Aleksandroviche Tokareve — uchenom i cheloveke [We Thank Fate for Meeting Him. About Sergey Aleksandrovich Tokarev — Scholar and Person], ed. by S. Ya. Kozlov and P. I. Puchkov. Moscow: Insitut etnologii i antropologii RAN. 31–40.
    2. Grigulevich, I. R. 1980. O Sotsial’noi Roli Religii (Mysli Religieveda po Povodu Myslei Etnografa) [On the Social Role of Religion (Thoughts of a Specialist of Religion on the Thoughts of a Specialist of Ethnography)]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 6: 61–66.
    3. Gromov, G. G. 1980. Nekotorye spornye voprosy izucheniia religii [Some Controversial Issues in the Study of Religion]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 5: 72–83.
    4. Kozlov, S. Ya. 1999. …I dol’she veka dlitsia zhizn’ (Zametki yubileinye i ne ochen’) [… The Life Lasts More Than a Hundred Years (Anniversary and Not So Anniversary Notes)]. Etnograficheskoe obozrenie 5: 3–15.
    5. Kryvelev, I. A. 1980. O sushchestvennom i nesushchestvennom v izuchenii religii [On the Essential and Non-essential in the Study of Religion]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 1: 72–79.
    6. Minkiavichius, Ya. V. 1980. O soderzhanii religii [On the Content of Religion]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 4: 88–97.
    7. Muraviev, Yu. A. 1980. Religiia: vera, illiuziia, znanie [Religion: Belief, Illusion, Knowledge]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 4: 80–87.
    8. Semenov, Yu. I. 1980. O sushchnosti religii [On the Essence of Religion]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 2: 49–63.
    9. Shakhnovich, M. I. 1980. Razvivat’ issledovanie problem religii [Developing the Study of the Problems of Religion]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 2: 84–87.
    10. Sherdakov, V. N. 1980. O glavnom v ponimanii religii [On the Essentials in Understanding Religion]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 2: 64–70.
    11. Solovei, T. D. 2022. Istoriia rossiiskoi etnologii v ocherkakh. XVIII — nachalo XXI v. [History of Russian Ethnology in Essays. 18th — early 21st century] Moscow: Etnosfera. 612 p.
    12. Teriukova, E. A. 2019. Tsentral’nyi antireligioznyi muzei v Moskve i izuchenie narodnoi religioznosti v SSSR v 1930–1940-kh godakh [The Central Antireligious Museum in Moscow and the Study of Popular Religiosity in the USSR in the 1930s–1940s]. In Trudy po istorii i antropologii religii (1929–1946) [Works on the History and Anthropology of Religion (1929–1946)], ed. by M. M. Shakhnovich. Saint Petersburg: Izdatel’stvo Sank-Peterburgskogo Universiteta. 18–28.
    13. Tokarev, S. A. 1957. Religioznye verovaniia vostochnoslavianskikh narodov XIX — nachala XX v. [Religious Beliefs of the East Slavic Peoples of the 19th — early 20th century]. Moscow; Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR. 164 p.
    14. Tokarev, S. A. 1958. Etnografiia narodov SSSR: istoricheskie osnovy byta i kul’tury [Ethnography of the USSR Peoples: Historical Foundations of Everyday Life and Culture]. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo Universiteta. 616 p.
    15. Tokarev, S. A. 1964a. Rannie formy religii i ikh razvitie [Early Forms of Religion and Their Evolution]. Moscow: Nauka. 399 p.
    16. Tokarev, S. A. 1964b. Religiia v istorii narodov mira [Religion in the History of the Peoples]. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo politicheskoi literatury. 559 p.
    17. Tokarev, S. A. 1979. O religii kak o sotsial’nom yavlenii (mysli etnografa) [On Religion as a Social Phenomenon (Thoughts of an Ethnographer)]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 3: 87–105.
    18. Tokarev, S. A. 1981. Eshche raz o religii kak o sotsial’nom yavlenii (otvet moim kritikam) [Once Again on Religion as a Social Phenomenon (a Response to my Critics)]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 1: 51–65.
    19. Tokarev, S. A. 1985. Pogrebal’nye obychai, ikh smysl i proiskhozhdenie [Burial Customs, Their Meanings and Origins]. Priroda 9: 82–87.
    20. Tokarev, S. A. 1995. Iz dnevnikov [From the Diaries]. In Blagodarim sud’bu za vstrechu s nim. O Sergee Aleksandroviche Tokareve — uchenom i cheloveke [We Thank Fate for Meeting Him. About Sergey Aleksandrovich Tokarev — Scholar and Person], ed. by S. Ya. Kozlov and P. I. Puchkov. Moscow: Insitut etnologii i antropologii RAN. 159–304.
    21. Tokarev, S. A. 2002. Pogrebal’nye obychai, ikh smysl i proiskhozhdenie [Burial Customs, Their Meanings and Origins]. Religiovedenie 4: 93–98.
    22. Tokarev, S. A. 2005. Religiia v istorii narodov mira [Religion in the History of the Peoples]. Moscow: Respublika. 543 p.
    23. Tokarev, S. A. 2020. Religioznye verovaniia vostochnoslavianskikh narodov XIX — nachala XX v. [Religious Beliefs of the East Slavic Peoples of the 19th — early 20th century]. Moscow: Lenand. 164 p.
    24. Tokarev, S. A. 2021. Rannie formy religii i ikh razvitie [Early Forms of Religion and Their Evolution]. Moscow: Lenand. 400 p.
    25. Tokareva, E. S. 2020. Sergei Aleksandrovich Tokarev i ego poezdka v Bolgariiu, Yugoslaviiu i Italiiu (1946–1947 gg.) [Sergei Aleksandrovich Tokarev and his Trip to Bulgaria, Yugoslavia and Italy (1946–1947)]. In S. A. Tokarev. Problemy Triesta i Yuliiskoi Krainy v poslevoennom uregulirovanii v Evrope. Dnevniki chlena chetyrekhstronnei Komissii ekspertov po provedeniiu italo-yugoslavskoi granitsy [S. A. Tokarev. Problems of Trieste and Julijska Krajina in the Post- war Regulation in Europe. Diaries of a Member of the Quadrilateral Commission of Experts on the Italian-Yugoslavian Border], ed. by E. S. Tokareva. Moscow: Indrik. 7–34.
    26. Tokareva, O. V. 1995. Kratkie biograficheskie svedeniia o S. A. Tokareve [Brief Biographical Notes on S. A. Tokarev]. In Blagodarim sud’bu za vstrechu s nim. O Sergee Aleksandroviche Tokareve — uchenom i cheloveke [We Thank Fate for Meeting Him. About Sergey Aleksandrovich Tokarev — Scholar and Person], ed. by S. Ya. Kozlov and P. I. Puchkov. Moscow: Insitut etnologii i antropologii RAN. 7–14.
    27. Ugrinovich, D. M. 1980. O marksistskom ponimanii religii [On the Marxist Understanding of Religion]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 1: 66–71.

Downloads

Published

22.12.2024

Issue

No. 4 (2024): Herald of Anthropology

Section

The Scientific Life of Sergei A. Tokarev