Sergey A. Tokarev's Conceptual Ideas on the Social Organization of the Yakuts in the 17th Century and the Modern Historiography

10.33876/2311-0546/2024-4/64-78

Authors

  • Andrian Borisov the Institute for Humanities Research and Indigenous Studies of the North. Russian Academy of the Sciences. Siberian branch — Federal Research Centre "The Yakut Scientific Centre" https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8285-6421

Abstract

The article discusses the outstanding contribution of S. A. Tokarev (1899–1985) to the study of the Yakuts’ social organization in the 17th century employing a modern theoretical and methodological approach. Although the researcher generally worked within the strict framework of the formational approach commonly accepted in Soviet historiography, sometimes he managed to go beyond it in an effort to be objective. This was possible due to his deep knowledge of not only ethnographic materials, but also of Russian written sources of the 17th century. He studied huge arrays of cursive columns from the funds of the Siberian Prikaz and the Yakut Voivode's Hut, stored in the central archives, and used them in a comparative analysis with other sources. The original concept of the social organization of the Yakuts in the 17th century that he developed in the 1930s and subsequently revised in his major works in the 1940–1950s, made an outstanding contribution to Russian historiography, supplemented it with new data and offered a holistic view of the historical and ethnographic realities of the Yakut late medieval society. However, S. A. Tokarev's intention to remain on reliable historical ground, based on specific documentary sources of the 17th century, provoked substantial criticism. His research was cast in a continuous search for the closest scientific definitions to the categories of social organization of the Yakuts, which he identified. He used the entire toolkit of theoretical approaches and research methods and his experience, based on the best traditions of Russian historical and ethnographic science. Modern achievements of Yakut studies of historical knowledge confirm the scientific significance and relevance of the main conclusions and observations of S. A. Tokarev.

Author Biography

  • Andrian Borisov, the Institute for Humanities Research and Indigenous Studies of the North. Russian Academy of the Sciences. Siberian branch — Federal Research Centre "The Yakut Scientific Centre"

    Borisov, Andrian A. — Dr. in History, Chief Researcher in the Center for Intellectual History and Culture, the Institute of the Humanities Research and the Indigenous Studies of the North, Russian Academy of Sciences, Siberian Branch — Federal Research Centre «The Yakut Scientific Centre of the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences» (Yakutsk, Russian Federation). E-mail: a_a_borisov@mail.ru ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8285-6421

    For citation: Borisov, A. A. 2024. Sergey A. Tokarev's Conceptual Ideas on the Social Organization of the Yakuts in the 17th Century and the Modern Historiography. Herald of Anthropology (Vestnik Antropologii) 4: 64–78.

    Funding: The research was carried out as the project under the state assignment No. 1023032900024-0-6.1.1 "Regional Governance of Yakutia in the Communicative Space of the Russian State: Social Aspect (17th — early 20th centuries)".

    References
    1. Bakhrushin, S. V., and S. A. Tokarev (eds.). 1953. Yakutiia v XVII veke [Yakutia in the 17th Century]. Yakutsk: Knizhnoe izdatel’stvo. 439 p.
    2. Bakhrushin, S. V. 1955a. Ostiatskie i vogul’skie kniazhestva v XVI i XVII v. [Ostyak and Vogul Principalities in the 16th and 17th Centuries]. In Nauchnye Trudy [Scientific Works], by S. V. Bakhrushin. Vol. 3. Moscow: Akademiia Nauk SSSR. 86–152.
    3. Bakhrushin, S. V. 1955b. Ocherednye zadachi istoricheskogo izucheniia Yakutii. [The Current Tasks of the Historical Study of Yakutia]. In Nauchnye Trudy [Scientific Works], by S. V. Bakhrushin. Vol. 3. Moscow: Akademiia nauk SSSR. 263–272.
    4. Barg, M. A. 1973. Problemy sotsial’noi istorii v osveshchenii sovremennoi zapadnoi medievistike [Problems of Social History in the Light of Modern Western Medieval Studies]. Moscow: Nauka. 232 p.
    5. Basharin, G. P. 1950. Obshchestvennyi stroi yakutov nachala XVII v. [The Social System of the Yakuts at the Beginning of the 17th Century]. Voprosy istorii 4: 91–102.
    6. Basharin, G. P. 2003. Istoriia agrarnykh otnoshenii v Yakutii. T.1. Agrarnye otnosheniia s drevnikh vremen do 1770-kh godov [History of Agrarian Relations in Yakutia. Vol. 1. Agrarian Relations from Ancient Times to the 1770s]. Moscow: Art-Fleks. 443 p.
    7. Borisov, A. A. 2010. Sotsial’naia istoriia iakutov v pozdnee Srednevekov’e i Novoe vremia: (opyt kompleksnogo issledovaniia) [Social History of the Yakuts in the Late Middle Ages and Modern Times: (a Comprehensive Study)]. Novosibirsk: Nauka. 269 p.
    8. Borisov, A. A. 2016. Ulus kak universal’naia forma politicheskoi i obshchestvennoi samoorganizatsii tiurkskikh i mongol’skikh narodov [Ulus as a Universal form of Political and Social Self-Organization of Turkic and Mongolian People]. Eurasian Nomadic Pastoralism: History, Culture, Environment. CNEAS Reports 22: 123–134.
    9. Gardanov, B. A. 1946. K voprosu o kharaktere obshchestvennogo stroia u yakutov v XVII v. [On the Nature of the Social System among the Yakuts in the 17th Century]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 2: 218–226.
    10. Gogolev, A. I. 1988. Sotsial’naia organizatsiia i traditsionnaia sem’ia yakutov v v XVII veke [Social Organization and Traditional Family of the Yakuts in the 17th Century]. In Sem’ia u narodov Sever- Vostoka SSSR: Sbornik nauchnykh trudov [Family among the Peoples of the North-East of the USSR: A Collection of Scientific Works], ed. by M. K. Pankratova. Yakutsk: YF SO AN SSSR. 89–98.
    11. Gurvich, I. S. 1955. K voprosu ob obshhestvennom stroe yakutov v XVII–XIX vekakh [On the Social Structure of the Yakuts in the 17th–20th Centuries]. Uchenye zapiski IYLI YF AN SSSR [Scientific Notes of ILLH YF AS USSR]. Vol. 3. Yakutsk. 3–17.
    12. Ivanov, V. F. 1992. Sotsial’no-ekonomicheskie otnosheniia v Yakutii (konets XVII — seredina XIX vv.). [Social and Economic Relations in Yakutia (Late 17th — mid-19th Centuries)]. Novosibirsk: Sibirskoe otdelenie. 228 p.
    13. Ivanov, V.N. 1966. Sotsial’no-ekonomicheskie otnosheniia u yakutov. XVII vek [Social and Economic Relations among the Yakuts. 17th century]. Yakutsk: Knizhnoe izdatel’stvo. 424 s.
    14. Kradin, N. N. 1995. Vozhdestvo: sovremennoe sostoianie i problemy izucheniia [Chiefdom: Current State and Problems of Study]. In Rannie formy politicheskoi organizatsii: ot pervobytnosti k gosudarstvennosti [Early Forms of Political Organization: from Primitiveness to Statehood], ed. by V. A. Popov. Moscow: Vostochnaia literatura RAN. 11–61.
    15. Kradin, N. N. 2000. Kochevniki, mir-imperii i sotsial’naia evoliutsiia [Nomads, World-Empires and Social Evolution]. In Al’ternativnye puti k tsivilizatsii [Alternative Paths to Civilization], ed. by E. V. Komarova. Moscow: Logos. 314–336.
    16. Kradin, N. N. 2019. Sovremennaia diskussiia o politogeneze u kochevnikov-skotovodov [Modern Discussion about Politogenesis among Nomadic Pastoralists]. Vostok 1: 6–23. https://doi.org/10.31857/S086919080003956-8
    17. Ksenofontov, G. V. 1935. Tezisy-konspekty “Ocherkov po drevnei istorii yakutov’ [Abstracts-Summaries of “Essays on the Ancient History of the Yakuts”]. Sbornik trudov NII yazyka i kul’tury pri SNK YASSR [Collection of Works of the Research Institute of Language and Culture under the Council of People’s Commissars of the Ukrainian ASSR], ed. by P. A. Oiunskii. Vol. 1. Yakutsk: Knizhnoe Izdatel’stvo. 73–97.
    18. Kushner, P. 1924. Ocherk razvitiia obshchestvennykh form [Essay on the Development of Social Forms]. Moscow: Kommunisticheskii universitet imeni Ya. M. Sverdlova. 430 p.
    19. Mauss, M. 1996. Obshhestva. Obmen. Lichnost’ [Societies. Exchange. Personality]. Moscow: «Vostochnaia literatura» RAN. 418 p.
    20. Mitrofanov, V. V. 2017. Problemy obshchestvennogo stroia i etnogeneza yakutov v otzyve S. V. Bakhrushina na knigu S. A. Tokareva [Problems of the Social System and Ethnogenesis of the Yakuts in the S. V. Bakhrushin’s Review on the Book by S. A. Tokarev]. Vestnik ugrovedeniia 1: 169–182.
    21. Parfenova, O. A. 2023. Traditsionnoe yakutskoe obshchestvo kontsa XVI — nachala XVII vv.: sotsial’nye struktury i vlast’ (istochniki, issledovaniia, diskussii) [Traditional Yakut society of the Late 16th–early 17th Centuries: Social Structures and Power (Sources, Research, Discussions)]. Severo-vostochnyi gumanitarnyi vestnik 3: 8–19. https://doi.org/10.25693/SVGV.2023.44.3.001
    22.Shirokogorov, S. M. 1923. Etnos. Issledovaniia osnovnykh printsipov izmeneniia etnicheskikh i etnograficheskikh iavlenii [Ethnos. Research into the Basic Principles of Changes in Ethnic and Ethnographic Phenomena]. Shanghai. 134 p.
    23. Shunkov, V. I, 1974. Voprosi agrarnoi istorii Rossii [Questions of Russian Agrarian History]. Moscow: Nauka. 376 p.
    24. Tokarev, S. A. 1941. Proiskhozhdenie yakutskoi narodnosti [Origin of the Yakut people]. Kratkie soobshheniia Instituta istorii material’noi kul’tury 9: 58–63.
    25. Tokarev, S. A. 1945. Obshhestvennyi stroi yakutov XVII–XVIII vv. [Social Structure of the Yakuts in the 17th-18th centuries]. Yakutsk: Knizhnoe Izdatel’stvo. 414 p.
    26. Trepavlov, V. V. 2000. Kanun gosudarstvennosti v olonkho (vzgliad istorika na yakutskii geroicheskii epos) [The Eve of Statehood in Olonkho (a Historian’s View of the Yakut Heroic Epic)]. In Olonkho — duhovnoe nasledie naroda Sakha [Olonkho — the Spiritual Heritage of the Sakha People], ed. by E. M. Maharov. Yakutsk: IGI AN RS (Y). 24–56.
    27. Ushnickii, V. V. 2018. Rol’ i mesto yakutskogo vozhdestva — toionata v upravlencheskoi strukture Rossiiskoi gosudarstvennosti v XVII v. [The Role and Place of the Yakut Chieftaincy Toyonat in the Administrative Institution of the Russian State in the 17th Century]. Problemy vostokovedeniia 4: 14–19. https://doi.org/10.24411/2223-0564-2018-10402
    28. Vasiliev, F. F. 1994. Ranneiakutskii ulus: sotsial’nye i voennye struktury [Early Yakut ulus: social and military structures]. In Etnos: traditsii i sovremennost’ [Ethnos: Traditions and Modernity], ed. by. V.N. Ivanov. Yakutsk: YNC SO RAN: 32–50.
    29. Vasiutin, S. A. 2016. Kontsepty “vozhdestvo’ i “gosudarstvo’ v otsenke politicheskikh institutov rannesrednevekovykh imperii Tsentral’noi Azii [The Concepts «Chiefdom» and «State» in The Evaluation of the Political Institutions in The Early Medieval Empires of Central Asia]. Vestnik Kemerovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta 4: 22–27. https://doi.org/10.21603/2078-8975-2016-4-22-27

Downloads

Published

22.12.2024

Issue

No. 4 (2024): Herald of Anthropology

Section

The Scientific Life of Sergei A. Tokarev