The Courage of Public Reason: Sergei Alexandrovich Tokarev as a Historiographer

DOI: 10.33876/2311-0546/2024-4/21-44

Authors

Keywords:

S. A. Tokarev, historiography, history of Russian ethnography, Department of Ethnography of Moscow State University, Institute of Ethnography, history of foreign ethnology

Abstract

S.A. Tokarev founded the Russian historiographical tradition, laying the conceptual framework for studying the history of Russian ethnography (its pre-Soviet period), and the origins and history of foreign ethnology. Here we regard historiography in its professional sense and not just as a functional appendage of scientific research. In the author's interpretation, historiography is not only (and not so much) a narrative about the past, but rather an internal dialogue of science and its self-reflection, a refined form of research into the past and modernity. S. A. Tokarev's appeal to this genre dates back to the turn of the 1940s–1950s, when a unique constellation of conditions for a successful historiographical search developed. These conditions were rooted both in the internal scientific dynamics (ethnography had acquired a stable status of an independent discipline and a high degree of maturity of professional discourse) and in external circumstances (here the ideological vector coincided with the public sentiment — the struggle against cosmopolitanism on the one hand and the legitimate pride of the victorious people on the other). In this context it was crucial to create a respectable historiographical tradition, which would highlight the significant (and in the Soviet era - the leading) role of Russian science in the global context. The author's interest is not in the analysis of S. A. Tokarev's historiographical concept, but rather in the circumstances and conflicts (interdisciplinary, political and ideological) surrounding the preparation and publication of vast historiographical works. The article touches upon the usually neglected topic about scientific preferences and the specifics of a scientist's research strategy as a projection of his psychotype. Why was it Tokarev who make the historiographical breakthrough? How was the "research laboratory" of a Soviet scientist organized, constrained by the rigid framework of planning, by external (political and ideological) and internal (scientific community) censorship, and under conditions of chronic academic and teaching overload? These issues are of considerable scientific interest.

Author Biography

  • Tatyana Solovey, M. V. Lomonosov Moscow State University

    Solovey, Tatyana D. — Doctor of History, Professor, Department of Ethnology, Faculty of History, Lomonosov Moscow State University (Moscow, Russian Federation). E-mail: tsolovei19@yandex.ru ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7453-297x

    For citation: Solovey, T. D. 2024. The Courage of Public Reason: Sergei Alexandrovich Tokarev as a Historiographer. Herald of Anthropology (Vestnik Antropologii) 4: 21–44.

    References
    1. Alekseev, V. P. 1988. S. A. Tokarev: lichnost’ v nauke. [S. A. Tokarev: Personality in Science]. In Blagodarim sud’bu za vstrechu s nim. (O Sergee Aleksandroviche Tokareve — uchenom i cheloveke) [We Thank the Fortune for Meeting Him (About Sergey Aleksandrovich Tokarev — the scientist and the man)], ed. by S. Ya. Kozlov and P. I. Puchkov. Moscow: IEA RAN. 24–30.
    2. Cheboksarov, N. N. 1946. Etnicheskaia antropologiia Germanii. (Kratkii istoricheskii ocherk) [Ethnic Anthropology of Germany (A Brief Historical Sketch)]. Kratkie soobshcheniia Instituta etnografii 1: 55–62.
    3. Cheboksarov, N. N. 1947. Kafedra etnografii istoricheskogo fakul’teta Moskovskogo ordena Lenina gosudarstvennogo universiteta imeni M. V. Lomonosova [Department of Ethnography of the Historical Faculty of the Moscow Order of Lenin State University named after M. V. Lomon- osov]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 1: 98–201.
    4. Cheboksarov, N. N. 1959. Osnovnye etapy razvitiia etnografii v Kitae [The Main Stages of the Development of Ethnography in China]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 6: 123–149.
    5. Chicherov, V. I. and N. M. Eliash. 1949. Lord Raglan — teoretik reaktsionnoi fol’kloristiki [Lord Raglan — a Theorist of Reactionary Folklore Studies]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 3: 216–217.
    6. Kosven, M. O. 1932. L. G. Morgan (1818–1881). Biografiia [L. G. Morgan (1818–1881). Biography]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 1: 9–43.
    7. Kosven, M. O. 1933. Bakhofen [Bakhofen]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 1: 98–140.
    8. Kosven, M. O. 1946a. Iz istorii problemy matriarkhata [From the History of the Matriarchy Problem]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 1: 31–58.
    9. Kosven, M. O. 1946b. Iz perepiski Bakhofena s Morganom [From Bachofen’s Correspondence with Morgan]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 1: 210–212.
    10. Kosven, M. O. 1946c. I. Ya. Bakhofen i russkaia nauka [I. Ya. Bachofen and Russian Science]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 3: 8–36.
    11. Kosven, M. O. 1948. Matriarkhat. Istoriia problemy, [The Matriarchy. The History of the Problem], ed. by S. P. Tolstov. Moscow; Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR. 329 p.
    12. Kosven, M. O. 1951. M. M. Kovalevskii kak etnograf Kavkaza. K 100-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia (1851–1951) [M. M. Kovalevsky as an Ethnographer of the Caucasus. On the 100th Anniversary (1851–1951)]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 4: 116–135.
    13. Kosven, M. O. 1952. Iz istorii rannei russkoi etnografii (XII–XVI vv.) [From the History of Early Russian Ethnography (12th–16th centuries)]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 4: 128–141.
    14. Kosven, M. O. 1953. 100-letniy yubilei russkoi etnograficheskoi pressy [100th Anniversary of the Russian Ethnographic Press]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 4: 56–69.
    15. Kosven, M. O. 1955a. Materialy po istorii etnograficheskogo izucheniia Kavkaza v russkoi nauke [Materials on the History of Ethnographic Study of the Caucasus in Russian Science]. In Kavkazskii etnograficheskii sbornik [Caucasian Ethnographic Collection], ed. by M. O. Kosven. Vol. I. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR. 265–374.
    16. Kosven, M. O. 1955b. Materialy k istorii russkoi etnografii XVII veka [Materials for the History of Russian Ethnography of the 17th Century]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 1: 126–150.
    17. Kosven, M. O. 1956a. G. F. Miller: k 125-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia [G. F. Miller: on the 125th Anniversary of His Birth]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 1: 72–76.
    18. Kosven, M. O. 1956b. Materialy k istorii rannei russkoi etnografii (XII–XVII vv.) [Materials on the History of Early Russian Ethnography (12th–17th centuries)]. In Ocherki istorii russkoi etnografii, fol’kloristiki i antropologii [Essays on the History of Russian Ethnography, Folklore Studies and Anthropology], ed. by V. K. Sokolova. Vol. 1. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR. 30–70.
    19. Kosven, M. O. 1958. Materialy po istorii etnograficheskogo izucheniia Kavkaza v russkoi nauke [Materials on the History of Ethnographic Study of the Caucasus in Russian Science]. In Kavkazskii etnograficheskii sbornik [Caucasian Ethnographic Collection], ed. by M. O. Kosven. Vol. II. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR. 139–274.
    20. Kosven, M. O. 1961. Etnograficheskie rezul’taty Velikoi Severnoi ekspeditsii 1733–1743 gg. [Ethnographic Results of the Great Northern Expedition of 1733–1743] In Sibirskii etnograficheskii sbornik [Siberian Ethnographic Collection], ed. by L. P. Potapov. Moscow; Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR. 167–212.
    21. Kosven, M. O. 1962. Materialy po istorii etnograficheskogo izucheniia Kavkaza v russkoi nauke [Materials on the History of Ethnographic Study of the Caucasus in Russian Science]. In Kavkazskii etnograficheskii sbornik [Caucasian Ethnographic Collection], ed. by L. I. Lavrov. Vol. III. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR. 158–288.
    22. Kozlov, S. Ya. 2004. Sergei Aleksandrovich Tokarev: “etnograficheskii universitet” [Sergey Alexandrovich Tokarev: “Ethnographic University”]. In Vydaiushchiesia otechestvennye etnologi i antropologi XX veka [The Outstanding Russian Ethnologists and Anthropologists of the 20th Century], ed. by. D. D. Tumarkin and V. A. Tishkov. Moscow: Nauka. 397–449.
    23. Kozlova, K. I. and N. N. Cheboksarov. 1955. Etnografiia v Moskovskom universitete [Ethnography at Moscow University]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 2: 100–111.
    24. Markov, G. E. 1979. Razvitie sovremennoi germanskoi burzhuaznoi etnologii [The Development of Modern German Bourgeois Ethnology]. In Etnografiia za rubezhom. Istoriograficheskie ocherki [Ethnography Abroad. Historiographical Sketches], ed. by Yu. V. Bromlei. Moscow: Nauka. 149–168.
    25. Markov, G. E. 1990. Iz istorii nemetskogo narodovedeniia [From the History of German Ethnology]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Seriia 8. Istoriia 2: 32–43.
    26. Markov, G. E. 1992. Nemetskoe narodovedenie ot nachala XX v. do 1933 g. [German Ethnology from the Beginning of the 20th century to 1933]. Etnograficheskoe obozrenie 4: 66–77.
    27. Markov, G. E. 1993. Ocherki istorii nemetskoi nauki o narodakh. Ch. I. Nemetskaia etnologiia [Essays on the History of German Science about Peoples. Pt. I. German Ethnology]. Moscow: IEA RAN. 391 p.; Ch. II. Nemetskoe narodovedenie [Pt. II. German Folk Studies]. Moscow: IEA RAN. 136 p.
    28. Markova, L. V. 1995. Sergei Aleksandrovich Tokarev: chelovek, uchenyi, pedagog [Sergey Alexandrovich Tokarev: a Man, a Scientist, a Teacher]. In Blagodarim sud’bu za vstrechu s nim (O Sergee Aleksandroviche Tokareve — uchenom i cheloveke) [We Thank the Fortune for Meeting Him (About Sergey Aleksandrovich Tokarev — the scientist and the man)], ed. by S. Ya.Kozlov and P. I. Puchkov. 41–57.
    29. Miskova, E. V. 2017. A. A. Nikishenkov. “Dvusmyslennost’ nashego remesla”. Grani otechestvennoi istoriografii v etnologii [A. A. Nikishenkov. “The Ambiguity of our Craft”. Facets of Russian Historiography in Ethnology]. In A. A. Nikishenkov. “Izobretaia traditsiiu” i sozdavaia “voobrazhaemoe soobshchestvo”. Sbornik statei pamiati A. A. Nikishenkova [A. A. Nikishenkov. ‘Inventing Tradition’ and Creating an “Imagined Community”. Collection of Articles in Memory of A. A. Nikishenkov], ed. by E. V. Miskova and A. V. Tutorskii. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Novyi khronograf’. 37–57.
    30. Nikishenkov, A. A. 1981. Funktsionalizm B. Malinovskogo i problema izucheniia rodstva, braka i sem’i v doklassovom obshchestve. (K voprosu o sootnoshenii teorii, metodologii i konkretnoi problematiki etnografii v britanskom funktsionalizme) [B. Malinovsky’s Functionalism and the Problem of Studying Kinship, Marriage and Family in a Pre-Class Society (On the Question of the Correlation of Theory, Methodology and Specific Issues of Ethnography in British Function- alism)]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Seriia 8. Istoriia 5: 57–69.
    31. Nikishenkov, A. A. 1982. Nauchnye shkoly v period stanovleniia sovremennoi britanskoi sotsial’noi antropologii (20–40-e gg. XX veka) [Scientific Schools During the Formation of Modern British Social Anthropology (20–40s of the 20th Century)]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 4: 55–66.
    32. Nikishenkov, A. A. 1983. Metod strukturnogo analiza A. R. Redkliff-Brauna i problema izucheniia otnoshenii rodstva v doklassovykh obshchestvakh [A. R. Radcliffe-Brown’s Method of Struc- tural Analysis and the Problem of Studying Gender Relations in Doctoral Societies]. In Puti razvitiia zarubezhnoi etnologii: Sbornik statei [Paths of Development of Foreign Ethnology: Collection of Articles], ed. by Yu. V. Bromlei. Moscow: Nauka. 5–24.
    33. Nikishenkov, A. A. 1986. Iz istorii angliiskoi etnografii. Kritika funktsionalizma [From the History of English Ethnography. Criticism of Functionalism]. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo universiteta. 213 p.
    34. Nikishenkov, A. A. 1993. O Bronislave Malinovskom i ego rabotakh [About Bronislaw Malinowski and his Works]. Etnograficheskoe obozrenie 6: 99–103.
    35. Rapoport, Yu. A. and Semenov, Yu. I. 2004. Sergei Pavlovich Tolstov: vydaiushchiisia etnograf, arkheolog, organizator nauki [Sergey Pavlovich Tolstov: an Outstanding Ethnographer, Archaeologist, Organizer of Science]. In Vydaiushchiesia otechestvennye etnologi i antropologi XX veka [The Outstanding Russian Ethnologists and Anthropologists of the 20th Century], ed. by V. A. Tishkov, D. D. Tumarkin. Moscow: Nauka. 184–232.
    36. Reshetov, A. M. 2004. Nikolai Nikolaevich Cheboksarov: portret uchenogo v kontekste ego vremeni [Nikolay Nikolaevich Cheboksary: Portrait of a Scientist in the Context of His Time]. In Vydaiushchiesia otechestvennye etnologi i antropologi XX veka [The Outstanding Russian Ethnologists and Anthropologists of the 20th Century], ed. by V. A. Tishkov, D. D. Tumarkin. Moscow: Nauka. 358–396.
    37. Semenov, Yu. I. 2003. O moem “puti v pervobytnost’’ [About “My Path to Primitiveness”]. In Akademik Yu. V. Bromlei i otechestvennaia etnologiia. 1960–1990-e gody [Academician Y. V. Bromley and Russian Ethnology. 1960–1990s], ed. by S. Ya. Kozlov. Moscow: Nauka. 164–211.
    38. Sharevskaia, B. I. 1948. Apologiia rasizma v amerikanskoi etnografii. (Shkola “izucheniia sovremennykh obshchin”) [An Apology for Racism in American Ethnography (School for the Study of “Modern Communities”)]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 2: 246–248.
    39. Sharevskaia, B. I. 1953a. Protiv antimarksistskikh izvrashchenii v osveshchenii voprosov pervobytnogo myshleniia i pervobytnoi religii [Against Anti-Marxist Perversions in the Coverage of Issues of Primitive Thinking and Primitive Religion]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 3: 9–26.
    40. Sharevskaia, B. I. 1953b. Etnografiia Frantsii v period pervoi mirovoi voiny i v poslevoennye gody [Ethnography of France during the First World War and in the Post-War Years]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 3: 208–214.
    41. Sharevskaia, B. I. and Pokrovskaia, L. 1956. Vliianie sovremennoi reaktsionnoi amerikanskoi sotsiologii na etnografiiu Frantsii [The Influence of Modern Reactionary American Sociology on the Ethnography of France]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 1: 140–145.
    42. Sharevskaia, B. I. 1959. “Etnologiia” i teologiia. (O zhurnale i institute “Anthropos”) [“Ethnology” and Theology. (About the “Anthropos” Journal and Institute)]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 6: 188–201.
    43. Sharevskaia, B. I. 1962. “Etnograficheskii metod” Marselia Griolia i voprosy metodologii v sovremennoi frantsuzskoi etnografii [The “Ethnographic Method” of Marcel Griaule and Questions of Methodology in Modern French Ethnography]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 6: 43–54.
    44. Solovei, T. D. 2004. Vlast’ i nauka v Rossii. Ocherki universitetskoi etnografii v distsiplinarnom kontekste (XIX — nachalo XXI v.) [Power and Science in Russia. Essays on University Ethnography in a Disciplinary Context (19th–early 21th century)]. Moscow: Prometei. 498 p.
    45. Solovei, T. D. 2022. Istoriia rossiiskoi etnologii v ocherkakh. XVIII — nachalo XXI v. [The History of Russian Ethnology in Essays. 18th — the beginning of the 21th century]. Moscow: Etnosfera. 612 p.
    46. Tokarev, S. A. 1945. Etnografiia v Akademii nauk (1745–1945) [Ethnography at the Academy of Sciences (1745–1945)]. Izvestiia AN SSSR. Seriia istorii i filosofii II (3): 191–200.
    47. Tokarev, S. A. 1946. Engel’s i sovremennaia etnografiia [Engels and Modern Ethnography]. Izvestiia AN SSSR. Seriia istorii i filosofii III: 17–30.
    48. Tokarev, S. A. 1948. Vklad russkikh uchenykh v mirovuiu etnograficheskuiu nauku [The Contribution of Russian Scientists to the World Ethnographic Science]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 2: 184–207.
    49. Tokarev, S. A. 1951. Osnovnye etapy razvitiia russkoi dorevoliutsionnoi i sovetskoi etnografii: Problema periodizatsii [The Main Stages of the Development of Russian Pre-Revolutionary and Soviet Ethnography: Problems of Periodization]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 2: 160–178.
    50. Tokarev, S. A. 1958b. Pervaia svodnaia etnograficheskaia rabota o narodakh Rossii (iz istorii russkoi etnografii XVIII v.) [The First Consolidated Ethnographic Work on the Peoples of Russia (From the History of Russian Ethnography of the XVIII century)]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Istoriko-filologicheskaia seriia 4: 113–128.
    51. Tokarev, S. A. 1958c. Venskaia shkola etnografii [Vienna School of Ethnography]. Vestnik istorii mirovoi kul’tury 3: 182–192.
    52. Tokarev, S. A. 1966. Istoriia russkoi etnografii. (Dooktiabr’skii period) [The History of Russian Ethnography. (Pre-October period)]. Moscow: Nauka. 453 p.
    53. Tokarev, S. A. 1971. Rannie etapy razvitiia sovetskoi etnograficheskoi nauki (1917 — seredina 1930-kh godov) [Early Stages of the Development of Soviet Ethnographic Science (1917 — mid-1930s)]. In Ocherki istorii russkoi etnografii, fol’kloristiki i antropologii [Essays on the History of Russian Ethnography, Folklore Studies and Anthropology], ed. by R. S. Lipets. Vol. V. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR. 111–120.
    54. Tokarev, S. A. 1974. Iz istorii etnograficheskikh issledovanii v Akademii nauk [From the History of Ethnographic Research at the Academy of Sciences]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 2: 11–19.
    55. Tokarev, S. A. 1978a. Istoki etnograficheskoi nauki. (Do serediny XIX v.) [The Origins of Ethnographic Science (Until the middle of the XIX century)]. Moscow: Nauka. 164 p.
    56. Tokarev, S. A. 1978b. Istoriia zarubezhnoi etnografii: Uchebnoe posobie [The History of Foreign Ethnography: A Textbook]. Moscow: Vysshaia shkola. 352 p.
    57. Tolstov, S. P. 1946. Etnografiia i sovremennost’ [Ethnography and Modernity]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 1: 3–11.
    58. Tolstov, S. P. 1947. Sovetskaia shkola v etnografii [The Soviet School of Ethnography]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 4: 8–28.
    59. Tolstov, S. P. 1950. Osnovnye zadachi i puti razvitiia sovetskoi etnografii [The Main Tasks and Ways of Development of Soviet Ethnography]. Kratkie soobshcheniia Instituta etnografii 12: 5–14.
    60. Tolstov, S. P. 1956. Itogi i perspektivy razvitiia etnograficheskoi nauki v SSSR [The Results and Prospects of the Development of Ethnographic Science in the USSR]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 3: 5–13.
    61. Tolstov, S. P. 1957. 40 let sovetskoi etnografii [40 Years of Soviet Ethnography]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 5: 31–55.
    62. Tolstov, S. P. 1960. Osnovnye teoreticheskie problemy sovremennoi sovetskoi etnografii [The Main Theoretical Problems of Modern Soviet Ethnography]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 6: 10–23.
    63. Zarinov, I. Yu. 2003. Issledovanie fenomenov “etnosa” i “etnichnosti”: nekotorye itogi i soobrazheniia [The Study of the Phenomena of “Ethnos” and “Ethnicity”: Some Results and Reflections]. In Akademik Yu. V. Bromlei i otechestvennaia etnologiia. 1960–1990-e gody [Academician Y. V. Bromley and Russian Ethnology. 1960–1990s], ed. by S. Ya. Kozlov. Moscow: Nauka. P. 18–36.

Downloads

Published

22.12.2024

Issue

No. 4 (2024): Herald of Anthropology

Section

The Scientific Life of Sergei A. Tokarev