«Naturalness» in Scottish Dancing: an ethnolinguistic perspective

DOI: 10.33876/2311-0546/2019-47-3/169-188

Abstract

The article explores various meanings of the concept «(un)natural» in written and spoken discourse devoted to traditional Scottish dancing. Analysing this concept alongside its co-occurent adjectives and adverbs in 18th–21st-century sources allows to better appreciate the semiotic complexity of the concept and its uses. The article highlights the seeming obviousness of what dancing naturally means to different kinds of stakeholders (dancers, teachers, spectators and researchers). It also emphasises the link between what is seen as natural dancing and people’s habits, both kinaesthetic, resulting from dance practice or the lack thereof, and stylistic or visual, grounded in spectators’ exposure to various manifestations of the Scottish dance repertoire.

References

1. Alferov, S.V. 2010. Moda na identichnost’ – mekhanizmy identifikatsii v semioticheskom pole gliantsevogo zhurnala [Identity in Fashion: Identification Mechanisms in the Semiotic Field of a Glossy Magazine]. Etnograficheskoe obozrenie 3: 107–119.
2. Alferov, S. 2013. Scottish Dancing and Patterns of Gender Identity. In Interculturalism, Meaning and Identity, edited by D. Boswell, R. O’Shea and E. Tzadik. Oxford: Inter-Disciplinary Press.
3. Arutiunov, S.A. 1994. Narodnye mekhanizmy iazykovoi traditsii [Ethnic Mechanics of a Language Tradition]. In Arutiunov S.A. et al. Yazyk – kul’tura – etnos. Moscow: Institut slavianovedeniia RAN.
4. Csikszentmihalyi, M. 2011. Potok: Psikhologiia optimal’nogo perezhivaniia [Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience]. Moscow: Smysl.
5. Gorelik, G.E. and V.Y. Frenkel’. 1990. Matvei Petrovich Bronshtein (1906–1938) [Matvey Petrovich Bronstein]. Moscow: Nauka.
6. Lotman, Y.M. 1992. Simvolika Peterburga i problemy semiotiki goroda [The Symbolism of Saint Petersburg and the Problem of City Semiotics]. In Lotman, Y.M. Izbrannye stat’i. Vol. 2. Tallinn: Aleksandra.
7. Lotman, Y.M. 2004. Pamiat’ kul’tury [Cultural Memory]. In Lotman, Y.M. Semiosfera. Saint-Petersburg: Iskusstvo-SPB.
8. Maksimov, L.V. 2013. Dilemma «estestvennosti» i «neestestvennosti» moral’nogo motiva [The Dilemma of «Naturalness» and «Unnaturalness» of a Moral Motive]. Eticheskaia mysl’ 13.
9. Tolstoi, N.I. 2013. Etnolingvistika v krugu gumanitarnykh distsiplin [Ethnoliguistics amongst Humanities]. In Tolstoy, N.I. and S.M. Tolstaya. Slavianskaia etnolingvistika: voprosy teorii. Moscow: Institut slavianovedeniia RAN.