Sergey A. Tokarev as an Expert and his Field Diaries as an Ethnographic Source

10.33876/2311-0546/2024-4/94-116

Authors

Keywords:

Sergey A. Tokarev, history of ethnology, ethnological expertise, autoethnography, Trieste, diary as a source

Abstract

The article is devoted to one of the most fascinating “episodes” in the scientific life of Sergey A. Tokarev, namely his work as an expert member of the International Commission for the Establishment of New Postwar Frontiers. This was the case when ethnographers' knowledge was in demand not only at the state level but also at the international one. In the 40s and 50s of the last century, one of the most pressing issues of international politics was the question of the statehood of Julijska Krajina (Croatian and Slovene; Engl. The Julian March) or Venezia Giulia (Italian; Engl. Julian Venetia). Trieste is a city and a region, which is a paradigmatic case for all historians and politicians dealing with borders and minorities. The so-called “Trieste model” is often recalled when dealing with the problem of disputed territories. Today, this historic territory is divided between three states: Italy, Slovenia, and Croatia. But such a division took a long time to be established, in which different players participated. The fate of the region was decided in several stages. The main criterion for drawing the border after World War II was the ethnic composition of the population in the disputed territories. The USSR played an important role in making the decision. Sergey A. Tokarev, a prominent Russian ethnographer, was a member of the commission that drew the borders. During his foreign trips in 1946–1947, S. A. Tokarev kept diaries in which he recorded daily everything that happened to him during the day, his observations during meetings and trips to Istria and northeast Italy. The diary is written in such detail that it is a living sketch of the life in the area studied by the Commission, which conveys the difficult atmosphere of those years. That is why the diary is of interest not only to scholars but also to a wide range of readers. After returning home, S. A. Tokarev began to prepare for publication an ethnographic work based on the materials of his diary, but he did not have time to complete this work. Only recently, for the last anniversary of Sergey Aleksandrovich, thanks to the initiative of his daughter, Evgenia Sergeevna, these diaries were published.

 

Author Biography

  • Marina Martynova, the Russian Academy of Sciences N. N. Miklouho-Maklay Institute of Ethnology and Anthropology

    Martynova, Marina Yu. — Dr. of History, Professor, Head of the Department for European Studies, the Russian Academy of Sciences N. N. Miklouho-Maklay Institute of Ethnology and Anthropology (Moscow, Russian Federation). E-mail: martynova@iea.ras.ru ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7280-7450

    For citation: Martynova, M. Yu. 2024. Sergey A. Tokarev as an Expert and his Field Diaries as an Ethnographic Source. Herald of Anthropology (Vestnik Antropologii) 4: 94–116.

    Funding: The study was carried out as a part of the research plan of the Russian Academy of Sciences N. N. Miklouho-Maklay Institute of Ethnology and Anthropology.

    References
    1. Kozlov, S. Ya. and P. I. Puchkov (eds.). 1995. Blagodarim sud’bu za vstrechu s nim. O Sergee Aleksandroviche Tokareve — uchenom i cheloveke [We Thank the Fortune for Meeting Him. About Sergey Aleksandrovich Tokarev — A Scholar and a Man]. 314 p.
    2. Krasnovskaya, N. A. 1971. Friuly: (istoriko-jetnograficheskie ocherki) [Friuli: (Historical and Ethnographic Sketches)], Moscow: Nauka. 185 p.
    3. Markova, L. V. 1995. Sergei Aleksandrovich Tokarev: chelovek, uchenyi, pedagog [Sergey Alexandrovich Tokarev: a Man, a Scientist, a Teacher]. In Blagodarim sud’bu za vstrechu s nim (O Sergee Aleksandroviche Tokareve — uchenom i cheloveke) [We Thank the Fortune for Meeting Him (About Sergey Aleksandrovich Tokarev — A Scholar and a Man)], ed. by S. Ya. Kozlov and P. I. Puchkov. 41–57.
    4. Martynova, M. Yu. 2020. Model’ Triesta i naselenie ital’jano-slavjanskogo pogranich’ja [Trieste Model and the Population of the Italian-Slavic Borderland]. In Tokarev, S. A. Problemy Triesta i Julijskoj Krajny v poslevoennom uregulirovanii v Evrope. Dnevniki chlena chetyrehstoronnej Komissii jekspertov po provedeniju italo-jugoslavskoj granicy [The Problems of Trieste and the Julian Krajina in the Postwar Settlement in Europe. Diaries of a Member of the Quadripartite Commission of Experts on the Italian–Yugoslav Boundary]. Moscow: Indrik. P. 55–63.
    5. Martynova, M. Yu. and T. D. Filimonova. 1981. Horvaty Istrii [Croats of Istria]. In Rasy i narody: Sovremennye etnicheskie i rasovye problemy [Races and Peoples: Contemporary Ethnic and Racial Problems], ed. by I. R. Grigulevich. Vol. 11. Moscow: Nauka. P. 176–194.
    6. Salkov, A. P. 2009. Problema Julijskoj Krajny (Venecii-Dzhulii) v sovetskoj mezhdunarodnoj politike (1918–1945 gg.) [The Problem of Julian Krajina (Venice-Giulia) in Soviet Foreign Policy (1918–1945)]. In Rossijskie i slavjanskie issledovanija [Russian and Slavic Studies], ed. by A. P. Salkov, O. A. Yanovsky et al. Vol. 5. Minsk: BGU. 9–30.
    7. Salkov, A. P. 2010. SSSR v diplomaticheskoj bor’be za uregulirovanie Jugoslavsko-Ital’janskogo konflikta vokrug Julijskoj Krajny i Triesta (ijul’ 1945 — ijul’ 1946 g.) [The USSR in the Diplomatic Struggle for the Settlement of the Yugoslav-Italian Conflict over Julian Krajina and Trieste (July 1945 — July 1946)]. In Rossijskie i slavjanskie issledovanija [Russian and Slavic Studies], ed. by A. P. Salkov, O. A. Yanovsky et al. Vol. 5. Minsk: BGU. 18–39.
    8. Salkov, A. P. 2020. Jugoslavsko-ital’janskij nacional’no-territorial’nyj konflikt v Julijskoj Krajne (Venecii-Dzhulii): balans istoricheskih i jetnicheskih argumentov na fone geopoliticheskih i ideologicheskih protivorechij (pervaja polovina XX veka) [The Yugoslav–Italian National–Territorial Conflict in Julian Krajina (Venice-Giulia): Balancing Historical and Ethnic Arguments against the Background of Geopolitical and Ideological Contradictions (first half of the 20th century)]. In Tokarev, S. A. Problemy Triesta i Julijskoj Krajny v poslevoennom uregulirovanii v Evrope. Dnevniki chlena chetyrehstoronnej Komissii jekspertov po provedeniju italo-jugoslavskoj granicy [The Problems of Trieste and the Julian Krajina in the Postwar Settlement in Europe. Diaries of a Member of the Quadripartite Commission of Experts on the Italian–Yugoslav Boundary]. Moscow: Indrik. 53–166.
    9. Tokarev, S. A. 1946a. Etnograficheskie nabljudenija v Balkanskih stranah (1946) [Ethnographic Observations in the Balkan Countries (1946)]. Sovetskaja etnografija 2: 200–210.
    10. Tokarev, S. A. 1946b. Iz novoj literatury o probleme Julijskoj Krajny [The New Literature on the Problem of the Julian Crane]. Sovetskaja etnografija 3: 162–175.
    11. Tokarev, S. A. 2020. Problemy Triesta i Julijskoj Krajny v poslevoennom uregulirovanii v Evrope. Dnevniki chlena chetyrehstoronnej Komissii jekspertov po provedeniju italo-jugoslavskoj granicy [The Problems of Trieste and the Julian Krajina in the Postwar Settlement in Europe. Diaries of a Member of the Quadripartite Commission of Experts on the Italian-Yugoslav Boundary]. Moscow: Indrik. 544 p.
    12. Tokarev, S. A. (ed.). 1968. Tipy sel’skogo zhilishha u narodov Zarubezhnoj Evropy [Types of Rural Dwellings in the Populations of Outside Europe]. Moscow: Nauka. 376 p.
    13. Tokareva, E. S. 2020. Sergej Aleksandrovich Tokarev i ego poezdki v Bolgariju, Jugoslaviju i Italiju (1946–1947 gg.) [Sergey Aleksandrovich Tokarev and his Trips to Bulgaria, Yugoslavia and Italy (1946–1947)]. In Tokarev, S. A. Problemy Triesta i Julijskoj Krajny v poslevoennom uregulirovanii v Evrope. Dnevniki chlena chetyrehstoronnej Komissii jekspertov po provedeniju italo-jugoslavskoj granicy [The Problems of Trieste and the Julian Krajina in the Postwar Settlement in Europe. Diaries of a Member of the Quadripartite Commission of Experts on the Italian–Yugoslav Boundary]. Moscow: Indrik. P. 7–54.
    14. Tolomeo, R. 2020. Ital’janskaja istoriografija, posvjashhennaja gorodu Triestu i vopros o provincii Dzhulija [Italian Historiography on the City of Trieste and the Question of the Province of Giulia]. In Tokarev, S. A. Problemy Triesta i Julijskoj Krajny v poslevoennom uregulirovanii v Evrope. Dnevniki chlena chetyrehstoronnej Komissii jekspertov po provedeniju italo-jugoslavskoj granicy [The Problems of Trieste and the Julian Krajina in the Postwar Settlement in Europe. Diaries of a Member of the Quadripartite Commission of Experts on the Italian–Yugoslav Boundary]. Moscow: Indrik. P. 167–180.

Downloads

Published

22.12.2024

Issue

No. 4 (2024): Herald of Anthropology

Section

The Scientific Life of Sergei A. Tokarev